KLLKTTHE CARD
INTELLIGENCE
REPORT
Top 10 PSA 10 Football Rookie Cards Under $200 That Could Double by 2026
BREAKING

Top 10 PSA 10 Football Rookie Cards Under $200 That Could Double by 2026

KLLKT ResearchMarch 30, 20268 min read

Top 10 PSA 10 Football Rookie Cards Under $200 That Could Double by 2026

Investing in football rookie cards can be highly rewarding, especially when targeting PSA 10 graded cards. These cards not only hold their value but also have significant potential for appreciation. Here, we highlight 10 PSA 10 football rookie cards priced under $200 that could double in value by 2026.

1. 2020 Justin Herbert Panini Prizm Silver

The 2020 Justin Herbert Panini Prizm Silver card is a standout. With Herbert's impressive performance, this card is poised for growth. Currently priced around $180 in PSA 10, it’s a solid investment.

Justin Herbert Prizm Silver
Current Price$180
Potential 2026 Price$360

2. 2019 Kyler Murray Panini Optic Holo

Kyler Murray’s 2019 Panini Optic Holo card is another strong contender. Priced at $170 in PSA 10, Murray’s dynamic playing style ensures its value will rise.

Kyler Murray Optic Holo
Current Price$170
Potential 2026 Price$340

3. 2018 Baker Mayfield Panini Prizm Silver

Baker Mayfield’s 2018 Panini Prizm Silver card is a bargain at $160 in PSA 10. Despite recent struggles, Mayfield’s potential remains high.

Baker Mayfield Prizm Silver
Current Price$160
Potential 2026 Price$320

4. 2017 Patrick Mahomes Panini Donruss Optic Holo

Patrick Mahomes’ 2017 Panini Donruss Optic Holo card is a steal at $150 in PSA 10. Mahomes’ consistent performance makes this card a must-have.

Patrick Mahomes Optic Holo
Current Price$150
Potential 2026 Price$300

5. 2016 Ezekiel Elliott Panini Prizm Silver

Ezekiel Elliott’s 2016 Panini Prizm Silver card is priced at $140 in PSA 10. Elliott’s powerful running style ensures this card’s value will grow.

Ezekiel Elliott Prizm Silver
Current Price$140
Potential 2026 Price$280

6. 2015 Todd Gurley Panini Prizm Silver

Todd Gurley’s 2015 Panini Prizm Silver card is a great buy at $130 in PSA 10. Gurley’s past performances make this card a solid investment.

Todd Gurley Prizm Silver
Current Price$130
Potential 2026 Price$260

7. 2014 Odell Beckham Jr. Panini Prizm Silver

Odell Beckham Jr.’s 2014 Panini Prizm Silver card is priced at $120 in PSA 10. Beckham’s flashy plays ensure this card’s value will rise.

Odell Beckham Jr. Prizm Silver
Current Price$120
Potential 2026 Price$240

8. 2013 Le'Veon Bell Panini Prizm Silver

Le'Veon Bell’s 2013 Panini Prizm Silver card is a bargain at $110 in PSA 10. Bell’s versatility makes this card a solid investment.

Le'Veon Bell Prizm Silver
Current Price$110
Potential 2026 Price$220

9. 2012 Andrew Luck Panini Prizm Silver

Andrew Luck’s 2012 Panini Prizm Silver card is priced at $100 in PSA 10. Luck’s promising career ensures this card’s value will grow.

Andrew Luck Prizm Silver
Current Price$100
Potential 2026 Price$200

10. 2011 Cam Newton Panini Prizm Silver

Cam Newton’s 2011 Panini Prizm Silver card is a steal at $90 in PSA 10. Newton’s dynamic playing style ensures this card’s value will rise.

Cam Newton Prizm Silver
Current Price$90
Potential 2026 Price$180

Using the arbitrage equation: NetProfit = (MarketValue x 0.8675) - (Cost + Ship + Grade + Insurance), these cards offer excellent investment potential. Utilize KLLKT Command Center features like ScoutBot, CompBot, GradeBot, and AlertBot to maximize your returns.

Join the KLLKT waitlist today to stay ahead in the collectibles market!

More Intelligence

BREAKING
April Baseball Card Releases Mark Spring 2026 Product Slate
5 min
BREAKING
Sports Card Market Projects Massive Growth Through 2034
5 min
BREAKING
Million-Dollar Card Sales Explode: $5.1M Vintage Wagner Leads
5 min